Comparison

Manual Screening vs. Tersen

Why spreadsheets and gut feel don't scale — and what to use instead.

By Tersen Team4 min readUpdated Mar 2026

The Manual Screening Workflow

Most recruiters follow the same pattern. It works for 10 resumes. It breaks at 50. It's actively harmful at 200+.

1

Open inbox

Scan subject lines, download attachments, try to remember which ones you've already seen.

2

Skim the resume

A quick skim. Look for the right job title, maybe a company name you recognize. Move on.

3

Gut-check decision

Yes, no, or maybe? No documented criteria. No evidence. Just a feeling.

4

Update the spreadsheet

Copy-paste the candidate name. Add a column for 'notes' that says 'looks good' or 'not a fit.'

The fundamental problem isn't that recruiters are bad at reading resumes. It's that the process itself doesn't scale. More volume means more fatigue, more inconsistency, and more qualified candidates slipping through the cracks.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Time per resume
ManualA quick skim, often re-read later
TersenEvery resume scored against the same Role Card, with the evidence behind each score
Consistency
ManualVaries by reviewer, mood, and time of day
TersenIdentical criteria applied to every candidate
Evidence trail
ManualNone — decisions live in the recruiter's head
TersenComplete record of what was matched and why
Scalability
ManualLinear — more resumes means more work
TersenUpload a whole batch; every resume is scored against the same Role Card
Cost per screen
ManualRecruiter time spent on every resume
TersenA flat monthly plan; recruiter time goes to decisions, not first reads
Bias risk
ManualUnconscious bias in every decision
TersenEvery score is tied to your written requirements and the resume's own lines
Keyword gaming
ManualEasily fooled by stuffed resumes
TersenAnalyzes context, duration, and recency
Handoffs
ManualEmail threads, spreadsheet chaos
TersenOne-click evidence-backed exports (CSV, JSON)

Ready to see it in action?

Try the interactive demo — no sign-up required.

The 200-Resume Test

What does screening 200 resumes for a single role actually look like?

Manual Approach

  • Attention drops as the pile grows
  • No evidence for decisions
  • Candidates #150-200 get the worst review

With Tersen

  • AI scores all 200 against the same Role Card
  • Candidate #1 and #200 read against the same Role Card
  • Every decision backed by evidence
  • The recruiter makes every call

When Manual Screening Still Makes Sense

To be fair, there are scenarios where manual review is the right call:

  • Executive-level hires with fewer than 10 applicants
  • Highly creative roles where portfolios matter more than resumes
  • Internal transfers where you already know the candidates

For everything else — especially volume hiring, technical roles, and any position that regularly attracts 50+ applicants — AI screening is dramatically more effective.

Related Reading

Start Screening Smarter

Replace spreadsheets and gut feel with evidence-based screening. Try Tersen free — no credit card required.